While John Wick, the grieving master assassin, may not be a very nice guy, actor Keanu Reeves is well known for being a stand-up dude. Notoriously shy, there are lots of stories floating around about nice things he’s done, but hard to get anything on the record, since the actor won’t confirm or deny many of these stories.

So, we sat down with the cast of John Wick 3: Parabellum and asked them to name the nicest thing Keanu Reeves did while on set. The answers ranged from sweet and simple, like Ian McShane revealing that Reeves brought him tea while on set, to Lance Reddick describing a touching moment between the two actors. Halle Berry, who recently joined the franchise, just laughed and revealed that punctuality actually counts for a lot.

John Wick 3: Parabellum hits theaters May 17.